September 5, 2020
Dear Mr Thakur/Sir
I still remember myself when the first time I had entered into the G. S. College after spending two years as a recluse and I was trying to change things around back in August 2013. I had already avoided college for a month from its commencement as you later came to know about the fact that how I fight shy of being a part of academic institutions.
I still hate them.
Fortunately because of this pandemic my college in Pune, which is Indira School of Business Studies or ISBS for short, has gone virtual. For someone like me, it's a treat. I can avoid the people, I can avoid the campus. I even wrote a blog about it and my batchmates really liked it.
It's a Teacher Day today and all I could think about my days back in G.S. especially associated with you and of course Rafiq Sir. I can't believe I had written 6 pages long letter when I had left the college without telling you. But I am happy that despite all these years and distance our Student-Teacher relationship is still strong and growing.
Last night I had a row with some of my batchmates and I didn't do that intentionally, something had triggered in me and I had lost it. A couple of friends asked me to open up to them but I didn't, despite it was getting so hard. I had done that mistake a few days back and decided strongly that I'd never repeat that mistake.
I once again felt like Charlie last night, actually, I've been feeling that for a week. So I open up youtube and watch "The Perks of Being a Wallflower" trailer and some scenes of the movie. You remember this title, don't you? Maybe in the tons of books at your home, this one will be lost, but The Perks of Being a Wallflower will always be in my heart as it reminds me of you.
You are Mr Anderson and I am that silent student in your class, who wasn't talking much to anyone, Charlie.
When I used to make an entry in the classroom, I don't know why everyone was just staring at me and that was making me really uncomfortable. I'd often find comfort in last benches, far from Teachers and Toppers. I always hated Schools and it was my time to hate college too and I did.
What kept me going on in G.S. was your lecture of English. I remember how were looking over all the students and looking for some particular one but in the class of over 150 I guess, I still managed to get into your eyes despite being mostly silent. I wasn't good in studies and needed internal marks to maintain good grades, so I answered the questions later on but at the beginning, it was you who made me to speak in class.
When I knew the answers but wouldn't speak it up. I wasn't participating much in-class activities, nor do I do that now. So I would often write answer on my register page and will ask anyone sitting beside me to answer that. Some would answer and some would be scared to as it might be wrong. But soon within two-three weeks, you noticed the pattern and one day you directly asked the boy beside me that is it really him who is knowing the answer and then suddenly left the focus from him.
But I was stunned as I had received your message that you had finally figured out it was me who was actually answering and then one day you talked to me when I had come to you about a difficulty in getting the meaning of a word from the book that I was reading:
"You should learn to participate. Why didn't you answer the questions?"
(Knowing that I had known the answers for all of them. I was quite.)
"You seem like a quiet boy. Are you making friends?"
(I was still quiet and nervous. I never had a good deal with a teacher in my life.)
"Have you even talked with anyone here apart from me?" (I nodded negatively.) "Hmm...so I am the probably the first person to talk with you this much."
(It was true. I was avoiding everyone from my class. I just wanted to do my time there and get out. I hated soul-sucking academic places. But my childhood friend then had asked me to make new friends there and if someone talks to me himself, I should chose that person to be my friend. And then I had said one of my favourite line of "The Perks of Being A Wallflower" which was reminding me of the same scene from it.)
"If my English professor is the only friend I make in G.S. that would be sort of depressing."
And you laughed heartily. "What did you say your name was?"
"Piyush, sir," I said. "Piyush Thorat."
"And you like books?"
"I consider them my friends."
"You may not know, of course, you are a fresher here in G.S."
"Actually I was here for my 11 and 12 too."
"Oh, so you already are familiar with the campus. They why do you look like you're into some unwanted/unfamiliar place? Like an innocent man forcefully put into some prison?"
"This is a prison."
And you laughed. You thought something for a while and continued.
"As I was saying, that you may not know, I like students who read books."
"And why is that, sir?" I was surprised because in my experience Teachers only liked those students who liked academic books and not some novels.
"Because I am a book lover myself."
Now I had understood why you were really good at capturing the essence of any poem or a chapter of English book.
"I've got a personal library at my home."And my god I was impressed. "Someday I'd show you."
"I'd be happy to see your collection," I answered.
"Do you have your own collection?"
This made me quiet for a moment. "I want to but my father doesn't like me reading these books. He wants me to ready only study books."
"And what is your father's profession?"
"He's a librarian, sir."
Later on in the class, I started to give answers by myself and soon it brought me the attention of whole B.Com classes. I was in first year and other years students were also meeting me up and I had no clue for what. They all said that we heard your name, it is said that you are different, long hair boy who don't talk much but knows the answers. You seem like a clever boy. And I would reply to them that maybe you guys really need to see my mark sheets.
Seeing my bonding with you often amazed other students. I was just escaping attention but it followed me way too much in G.S. Then one incidence where one teacher from Grant section teaching accounts along with our late Rafiq Sir, I had told the answer of the difficult problem which was on the board to the class topper and that came out right answer. I was looking at Rafiq sir he had figured that out and I was just looking at him like I really need to get out of the class because I have to eat Samosa because I am damn hungry and he would imply that "Have patience."
I guess that topper had spoken about it to others and talks were spread about me but I wasn't really caring about it as long as I was enjoying my class with you. I remember two funny moments in campus:
ONE
When one Saturday I was roaming in the campus because I was bored of lectures and was thinking to spend my time out of the class then I saw you in one classroom and as I was passing by you called me.
"Piyush."
And I stopped and came back to the classroom door.
"Where are you roaming?"
"I just don't want to attain lectures today."
"Are you not enjoying my lectures too?"
"No sir, that's not the case."
"Then why are you not in the class right now?"
"It's your lecture now?"
"Yes. Get inside the classroom."
And as I came inside all I saw there were girls and came back outside.
"But Sir there are no students."
"Who are they?"
"They are all girls." and you were amused.
"Aren't they students?"
"They are but I'd feel too uncomfortable sitting in a class full of girls only."
"There are few boys too sitting in the back."
"Oh...then I guess I shall need few more."
"Are you seriously shying to sit in the class with them?"
Seeing my expressions you laughed and said.
"What will you do when you get married?"
"To a girl?"
"Well that's often the case but if you want to get married to a boy then..."
And then all the girls from the class were laughing and I was a lot embarrassed.
"No... that's not what I meant, sir. But the thing is I don't ever wanna get married actually."
"Did someone break your heart?"
"Not yet, sir."
"Alright good. Now get into the class, I'm done pulling your legs." and you laughed.
TWO
In the hallway once I and Bhavesh were having a talk and by my one reply, he was so impressed that he hugged me so tightly and said would kiss me for my words and then you just saw us and that cast really wrong impression.
And you were like, "So that's where you are comfortable."
"No. No. Sir you are getting me wrong."
"Piyush, now is my lecture and what are you doing out again? Get into the classroom."
"Yes sir." and Bhavesh was laughing and teasing me a lot.
Then as you were heading to the classroom and I was walking along with you explaining that I am totally heterosexual. And then you said to me putting your palm on my shoulder that you just enjoy pulling my legs sometimes with your sarcasm and I shouldn't feel offended.
I don't actually.
But the things is that when we both had entered the classroom at the same time, other students had weird unbelievable stare at me. When I went on my bench the guy beside me asked me,
"What, are you guys pals now?"
And I laughed over it and replied, "Sort of."
After that whenever I entered in a classroom all the guys made cheerful noise and that made me feel so awesome sometimes but I was getting scared too of that much attention.
Years ago Nitin Bhise, my classmate back then in G.S., had called me and made me talk to other batchmates too. I was taken aback and had asked him why did he do that. He said that I'm still a good friend for him. I remember I had helped him to cheat in Economics and Accounts, Rafiq sir had seen that and later on when Nitin was passed, Sir had asked him to thank me. I was happy he was passed into those difficult subject but then the amusing part was when I got the intimidating stare from Rafiq sir, and it had really good reason. I deserved that. I had helped Nitin to get pass in Economics while I had failed in it myself.
And the second subject that I had failed into was, yes yours, English. Everyone in G.S. was surprised to see me failed in English but I got the funniest reaction from my family. They were like, "You failed in ENGLISH? ENGLISH? I mean it is understandable that you can fail in Marathi, but ENGLISH?"
I had failed in Marathi in my 10th and 12th but had managed to get good marks in English while I was a Marathi medium student. I guess my life is full of ironies.
As you came to know about my Exam Phobia and difficulty to mix with people, I guess, it's not that much of an irony after all.
Then in my second year as I had a fight in college, I had left it without letting anyone know my decision and then back in January 2016, Rifq sir had called me and had asked me to visit G.S. after reading my letter to both of you.
When I came to college after a year then everyone was quite surprised all of them were staring at me as I and Rafiq sir were walking on campus together, conversing about me and my life. Around 50 students stood there staring at us then Rafiq sir had to ask them to go into the class then he talked to me something that no teacher ever talked to me.
"You were before my eyes for two years. And as a teacher, I feel ashamed for failing to understand your problems." He sounded so serious and I was shocked. No teacher ever gave a damn about me and now he's the one actually caring for me. He said, "I also came to know that you were suicidal, Mr Thorat and even had gone to commit it."
And I was subdued by his words. This is the first time I was scared of him as a student.
"You know, nobody much knows of it but when I was of your age I was also suicidal and at that time it was my father who talked me out of it. He's not in this world now but I remember his words. And I know how it feels to feel an outcast. I just want you to know that you are not alone. You have us." he meant you too. "So if you ever feel depressed or get some stupid thoughts of ending your life, just call me and don't you even dare to take such step in life."
I nodded quietly. He was feeling emotional but suppressed it. "You can do it, Mr. Thorat. Don't give up."
And then you were passing by a hallway and you saw me with him and said my name with surprise, "PIYUSH."
"May God save you from him now," said Rafiq sir and I wished the same. I knew I'd get a furious reply from you for not being honest with you.
Then we went to your computer lab and were talking and you were angry that I didn't tell you about the issues, understandable but still surprising that a teacher will really care about me. But then again, you are Mr Anderson to my Charlie.
There, our talk was the most inspiring moment for me.
"Why would you even consider to do such things? And why are you depressed?"
"There are lots of things. I wouldn't be able to explain it to you."
"Is it your studies? Just leave it if it is killing your soul."
"And then do what? Work in some hotel, cleaning tables?"
"Are you really like those materialistic people in the world? Because as much as I have figured you out, you don't really care about materialistic things."
"I already feel horrible for being nothing compared to those guys in my class."
"Are you comparing yourself with them? Those idiots who think that they are successful in life because they got few extra marks from someone else in their class? There are thousands of classroom every year and there are thousands of such idiots put in them, it is rare to find someone holding an interest in literature and music."
"I don't even know if I can write anything. What if I make an attempt and fail so horribly? I'd be a loser even there too as I am here in my classes."
"If you are afraid of being a bad writer and that's why you won't try to become one then you are the stupidest person I have ever seen because if you think being a good manager in some company will make everything okay with you then you are wrong. Be a bad one at what you really are than being good at something that you really aren't."
I went back to home after our talk and met my then best friend Juno. I talked to her about it and asked her to help me out for studies. Rafiq sir didn't want me to give up and you didn't want me to suffer for the things I didn't like. I had both teachers to listen to and I decided to find a way through that.
She helped me and I completed my graduation in first-class in Amravati and I was out of your touch for years. Mostly my batchmates will ask me that when I am good at studies then why don't I try to make the top, why do I settle for good marks and be okay with it. They didn't know what I wanted to be, academics was to get a job, also to follow what Rafiq sir had said.
Then back in January 2018, a very shattering news came to me. Rafiq sir was no more. Heart attack in his thirties. Such a young age to go and I was so shocked. I asked you just one question that "Is it true?"
and you replied, "Sadly, yes."
I was so shattered by the news. I was trying to focus on my studies but seeing my difficulties my brother, Abhijeet told me to take time to grieve. It still stings me that when I'll have a job one day in future, he wouldn't be there to see it. He would never know. So sometimes I wonder, is there even any point in going on with the old promises?
I was having something for you too. I was writing a book sir and wanted to surprise you. And when it was to published I just wanted to say you that, I've made it Sir. And I just wanted to see you feeling proud of me, that I fought and got what I wanted.
But, after writing 180 pages I am finally giving up the book. I loved that story a lot. It was based upon my friendship with Juno and had really great scenes in it but sadly those exact scenes have become a torture to me. I know I have read that "The Old Man and the Sea." book and I must not give up and hold on no matter how painful things get. But it is affecting my performance here in PGDM too and in the worst way it is affecting me. Very valuable people lost by the mistake of one and I am the one paying the price for it. When you have old good memories they eventually become torture when your present is mundane.
I guess fear of poverty is greater than passion of dream. It hurts me to fail to bring that reality in my life now I am so nihilistic. I am reading Fredrich Nietzsche's Beyond Good and Evil, I hope that will help with this pain that I am going through.
I am sorry that I am a sad story, that's why I said I feel like Charlie after many years.
But not everything is sad in my life. I still have issues with Thorat Sir and don't feel connected with my parents and that's the more reason I guess I miss Pamela (David story character) but there is my best friend, Hrishi and he is an idiot. And I hate him a lot because he talks all the time about money. And he's really bad at handling emotions, even for his own things in life, he just suppresses it. But he's supportive and tries his best to be there for me so even if sometimes I hate him for some reasons I can't say it to him. I love him, he's my brother and he wants me to make new friends in my life, despite I feel suffocation in PGDM.
I am not like those who want to make new friends, I am often happy with my old ones and intend to keep them but it often happens that my old friends got some new friends and now we are not much in contact. So when Hrishi asks me to find some new friends in my new college in Pune, I sometimes feel like he is preparing me for the same thing. The thing is if I have one good friend then I don't really need anyone but situations are teachings me new lessons in life and I have been trying to make new friends.
So in ISBS, I am trying to make friends, all I really want to be myself, a silent introvert and keeps away from all the drama but time is really forcing me to be friends with people. And I am trying, as I am saying it repeatedly. I've made few friends, one is also an introvert and her family owns restaurants in Pune, so I've made plans with her for Sea Food. She's gonna teach me how to have it, I haven't had seafood, so I really don't know how to have crabs, shells and Prawns, all I know how to have a fish.
Another friend of mine, well as she read my short story of David and came to know about my interest in literature and books, and then recently when she found out that I am currently writing a story for my high school crush on my blog, so she requested me that if I ever write a story based on my time in ISBS, her name would not be changed and should be as it is. I guess that gives her lots of happiness seeing the part of the story. I smiled delightedly and agreed to her wish. She's also gonna help me to find a real-life Alexa who shall have interest in books too.
I got one good friend too, he's from Amravati and he's sort of too emotional chubby guy. He has a crush on a mam and I make memes on him and entertain the whole section by it. I hope he doesn't mind it. He's interested in movies too and takes my suggestions for movies. It feels good. And some are just I talk to and I want to be on good terms with almost everyone but I must admit with some I already had conflicts. Some I thought would be really good friends to me but I guess they wouldn't be. And that's fine... I don't have to like everyone there and not everyone has to like me. I just need a handful of friends and I can be happy as hell.
Some of them are really curious about my age and I keep it a mystery. When they keep badgering that question to me then I answer them that I was born at a time when whole India was in chaos. They get confused and I get amused because then they stop asking me that. I hope one day one of them will figure that out, it's not that hard.
Don't worry about me Thakur Sir, I'll be alright there. I want to make you proud and one day I will. I know I have taken a vow that I shall not show you my face until I get a job and on that day I will return to you.
P.S.: There is a mam in my new college with whom I often talk via mails about books. It seems here the time will go better. She suggests me books and I do read them and leave her my review. And This year my challenge is to read 48 books, I am past 24 up to now which is behind the schedule but college is keeping me busy as hell.
It is a page from "The Perks of Being a Wallflower." I am so happy that it was the first book that I had gifted you. This also shows that the pattern of the blog is as same as the writing of the book.
This is me these days...happy and sad...and it's really weird.
This reminds me of that friend who had asked me to keep her name as it is if I write any story on my life in ISBS. I will make her find me a bookish Girlfriend... I guess that's a nice plot.
I hope I'll get good, trustworthy friends there.
But until then...
I am dying to feel INFINITE.









